WYNDHAM
Home » News » Rethink ‘pretend hospital’

Rethink ‘pretend hospital’

A local doctor is urging the state government to reconsider its plan to build the Point Cook Community Hospital.

In the lead up to the November 2018 election, the state government announced it would spend $675 million to build 10 community hospitals in major growth areas, including Point Cook.

The hospital was slated to open at some point in 2026 after several years of delay.

Dr Joe Garra said that specialist services such as chemotherapy and dialysis treatment that will be provided when the facility eventually opens could have been provided at Werribee Mercy.

“It is nothing that couldn’t have been done at Werribee Mercy by giving more funding to the bigger hospital up the road, which would have been a much more efficient use of money,” he said.

“We just need to make Werribee Mercy bigger because we already have the infrastructure there– you don’t need two hospitals that close together.

“All that stuff is already there, it’s not that difficult to make a hospital bigger.”

Dr Garra also said that the name of the facility does not accurately reflect its role.

“They are being a bit disingenuous calling it a community hospital– to the general public that is somewhere you can go and stay overnight for treatment,” he said.

“It’s great having extra services, but to call it a community hospital is a bit of a stretch.

“I call it Point Cook day clinic, because it’s not what people think it is supposed to be.

“Its basically a fancy community day facility.”

Dr Garra urged the state government reconsidered the project before construction starts and consider a better way to use health resources.

“It has taken a long time to build a little day clinic– it puzzles me why they just didn’t give it to the existing hospital.”

Star Weekly understands that the state government is currently doubling the emergency department at Werribee Mercy. Once completed the emergency department will cater to more than 25,000 patients a year.

The state government was contacted for comment on its community hospital plans.

Digital Editions


  • Abbas embracing leadership

    Abbas embracing leadership

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 528206 Abbas Ibrahim is the Wyndham Young Person of the Month for January. Dedicated to encouraging inclusion, Abbas aims…

More News

  • West is best this Midsumma

    West is best this Midsumma

    Midsumma Westside is back again, with plenty of events happening across Melbourne’s western suburbs between 18 January until 8 February. Georgia Tacey dives into all the events happening over the…

  • Community Calendar

    Community Calendar

    Live Well For Life Group IPC Health is hosting a free five-week program that will cover healthy lifestyle changes, including expert tips on heart health, diabetes, stroke prevention, nutrition, exercise…

  • From the archives

    From the archives

    Star Weekly looks back at the pages of our predecessors. 40 years ago 22 January, 1986 Werribee MLA Ken Coghill last week delivered a message to fellow drug testing centre…

  • Imports bolster Wyndham

    Imports bolster Wyndham

    Wyndham has locked in a couple of key pieces as the side prepares for the Big V women’s division 1 competition. Dropping down to division 1 after a tough 2025…

  • Turkish coffee and conversation

    Turkish coffee and conversation

    The Turkish Coffee Club Project was presented to Wyndham council on Tuesday 2 December, outlining the struggles of older Turkish and Turkish Cypriot ladies in accessing community services. The Wyndham…

  • Serving up more public transport for Australian Open

    Serving up more public transport for Australian Open

    Thousands of extra public transport services will be available for tennis fans heading to the Australian Open. Public and Active Transport Minister Gabrielle Williams announced that almost 5000 extra trams,…

  • Dumping rebate welcomed

    Dumping rebate welcomed

    Wyndham council has welcomed the state government’s dumping clean-up rebate. The state government recently opened the illegal dumping clean-up rebate program, through which councils and public land managers can apply…

  • Register for free business expo

    Register for free business expo

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 209276 Local businesses are encouraged to register for one of the area’s biggest networking opportunities. Exhibitor applications are open until 8 March for local…

  • Sweet ways to keep cool

    Sweet ways to keep cool

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 527634 As temperatures soared above 40 degrees on Friday 9 January, locals did everything they could to keep cool, calm and collected. In Tarneit,…

  • Bragging rights on the line

    Bragging rights on the line

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 525259 It’s a battle for top four spots and bragging rights in the Point Cook derby in the Victorian Turf Cricket Association Roy Picone…